Media Hub by Drone Federation India

Counter Drone Strategy Emerges as India’s Next Security Priority

Article

Drones are revolutionising applications for both civilian and military purposes. This accelerated the adoption of drones in recent years. As the number of drones increases, the threats caused by drones increase. The 2021 attack is a sign of these threats. Two low-flying drones attacked the Air Force base in Jammu, dropped Improvised Explosive Devices (IEDs) on the roof of the building, injuring two personnel. This was the first-ever attack by drones on an Indian military establishment. Between 2020 and 2022, approximately 492 drone sightings were observed on the India-Pakistan International Border. Beyond military attacks, the use of drones is being noticed in cross-border smuggling, narco-terrorism, and espionage. In the Punjab and Jammu sectors, reports surfaced about drone sightings, with the illicit shipping of arms, explosives, and narcotics. This expands the scenario of threats and shows that the misuse of drones is not constrained to warfare but involves organised crime and terrorism. These drone incidents highlight the open threat that drones pose today and the need for a robust counter-strategy. CUAS (Counter-Unmanned Aviation Systems) addresses this growing concern to ensure national security by protecting critical infrastructures.

A Counter-Unmanned Aircraft System (CUAS) is a set of integrated systems that use diverse technologies to detect, track, identify, and neutralise drones detected as unauthorised or uncooperative. According to the Joint Research Centre (JRC) of the European Commission, Non-cooperative drones are classified based on the type of non-cooperation into criminal, illegal and amateur. Intentional use for malicious activities is criminal. Unauthorised drone operations are considered Illegal, and flights with unawareness and negligence fall under Amateur. The intention or motivation further amplifies the need for robust CUAS solutions. CUAS identifies drone activity, supported by interception or jamming devices to disable drones. CUAS can be categorised based on their operational scope. Understanding the types of CUAS is crucial to know which type is needed in different threat environments.

The architecture of a robust CUAS integrates multiple components to provide a multi-layered defence. The major elements of CUAS include Sensors, C4ISR (Command, Control, Communications, Computers, Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance) and Effectors. Acoustic Sensors sense sounds of drones, RF Sensors identify radio frequency signals used for drone communication and navigation, and Direction Finder determines the source of drone signals. Radar Systems and Optical Sensors for detection, visual identification and payload assessment. The challenge for India is not the availability of these technologies, but their integration into a seamless, AI-enabled detection network. C4ISR acts as a brain that processes data using AI and machine learning for threat assessment, fuses sensor inputs into a single version and supports decision-making for appropriate mitigation strategies. Effectors neutralise threats through hard or soft kill methods. Hard kill refers to physically destroying or capturing the drone, and soft kill counters the drone without physical damage using electronic or cyber-based techniques. Examples of effectors include Jamming Systems for RF and GNSS jamming to disrupt drone communication, Directed Energy Weapons (DEWs), including lasers or high-power microwaves are for precise hard killing and nets to catch them physically. Other countermeasures include dazzling, water cannons, interceptor drones, etc. Modern CUAS effectiveness lies not in isolated technologies but in sensor fusion and intelligent control. All sensors must be integrated through AI-driven command-and-control systems to process multi-sensor inputs in real time. This stacked approach is crucial for tackling emerging threats. India must prioritise scalable soft-kill systems for urban and civilian zones, while reserving hard-kill effectors for high-value defence assets.

The current deployment of CUAS in India is limited to border areas and during military conflicts on an Ad-hoc basis. India shares borders of 3488 km and 3323 km with China and Pakistan, respectively. The current geopolitical tensions and India’s 6811 km border with these countries may lead to significant drone threats. The 2021 Jammu IAF station attack highlighted the temporary nature of the current CUAS deployment. These drone threats are not just limited to the border but are relevant for infrastructures inside the country as well. Drones have been reportedly sighted or intercepted near nuclear facilities, military bases, government buildings, and other critical assets. In 2017,drone-like objects were spotted at Delhi's IGI Airport, approximately 15 flights were diverted, and over 20 were delayed after the sighting. Conventional systems that are installed to mitigate these threats are expensive. Besides, no binding Standard Operating Procedures (SOPs) exist regarding the deployment of these systems. Deployment is therefore largely reactive in nature and aimed at addressing an immediate threat without adherence to any framework. Current deployments focus on short-term issues, but a structured approach for national security must also address long-term challenges.

Most developed nations have realised the need for a counter-drone strategy. The USA established the Joint C-UAS Office (JCO) in 2019 with the purpose of leading, synchronising, and directing C-sUAS (Countering small Unmanned Aircraft System) activities by looking at doctrine to establish joint solutions with a common medium to address current and future emerging sUAS threats. Through the JCO, the Department will ensure there is consistency of approach, technology, operational constructs, and developmental intent for joint C-sUAS solutions. The NPSA(National Protection Security Authority) in the United Kingdom coordinates with the counter-drone unit of the Home Office and other government agencies to maximise efficiencies and reduce confusion in the implementation of credible anti-drone solutions. In India, current irregular practices are largely event-driven and fragmented among agencies. A codified doctrine must be put in place to ensure that military, paramilitary, and civil responses with clarity of authority and rules of engagement

India must formulate a counter-drone strategy by structuring CUAS deployment to enhance effectiveness by focusing on different aspects. Threat modelling and assessment are the first crucial aspects to be focused on. This includes identifying potential threats, risk analysis on these threats based on probability of occurrence, vulnerability, strength of impact, while considering other external factors. Another aspect which extends this is the identification of critical infrastructure. Critical infrastructures are facilities essential to national security, public safety and economic stability, whose disruption impacts the common functioning of the country. For instance, airports, plants for nuclear or hydro energy, and defence and security centres serving centres of communication, banks, food and water supply chains, health protection centres, transport networks, rescue services, public administration, and storage of chemical/radioactive materials.

Merging threat assessment and critical infrastructure identification, these infrastructures can be classified into high, medium or low priority based on criticality and threat exposure. For critical infrastructure protection, a tier-based system may also be used based on value and risk. Tier I includes highly valuable and high-risk targets such as airports, refineries, nuclear plants, and defence installations. Tier II entities are medium-risk assets, including major dams, power plants, and ports. Tier III comprises lower-priority but still essential sites, including state administrative hubs and logistic nodes. This structured classification allows resources to be allocated proportionately to threat exposure.

The type of CUAS to be deployed varies depending on the priority and threat percentage. For strict implementation, SOPs should be drafted accordingly based on intent and the country’s scenario. The country’s scenario refers to peacetime and wartime. During peacetime, the emphasis must be on prevention, monitoring and countermeasures to minimise the collateral damage. During wartime, a focus on rapid detection, tracking to neutralise immediate threats is needed. These approaches can be culminated into a CUAS planning checklist. This checklist leads to the type of deployment. The 4Ps of counter-drone strategy (Prevent, Pursue, Prepare, and Respond) must be considered by India. Preventing threats, pursuing targets, protecting critical infrastructure, and preparing for potential future threats. These strategies should be undertaken under clear roadmaps and timelines.

After the Pahalgam attack, India responded with Operation Sindoor. Operation Sindoor was a planned response targeting the terrorist establishments in Pakistan responsible for the attack. This operation involved the integration of loitering munitions, anti-drone systems and sophisticated air defence platforms. Later, Pakistan sent a series of drones, which India successfully thwarted at 26 locations. Although the threat was neutralised, expensive and conventional air defence systems were used instead of cost-effective, robust C-UAS. This highlights the critical need for robust CUAS in India. The global anti-drone market is projected to reach $5.2 billion by 2028. This is an opportunity for India to tap the global market and move closer to the 2030 vision global drone hub. Drone forensics from captured enemy UAVs must be shared with Indian vendors to improve indigenous CUAS . Indigenous development of CUAS solutions can only originate from a multi-layered plan involving various stakeholder levels through the holy trinity of the industry, academia, and government. Such an approach would allow for thorough threat-modelling, safeguarding critical infrastructure, and establishing SOPs similar to wartime and peacetime scenarios. By giving the highest priority to CUAS development, India could tackle the rising threat of drones and be positioned as a global leader. Thus, robust CUAS systems are not just a need but a necessity for India.

“Yesterday’s weapons can’t win today’s wars, tomorrow’s technology is needed to fight today’s battles”

- CDS General Anil Chauhan

References:

https://indrajaal.in/insights/strengthening-military-intelligence-the-role-of-counter-drone-systems/

https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/indias-homegrown-bhargavastra-counter-swarm-drone-system-test-fired-successfully/article69575021.ece

https://www.lifeofsoldiers.com/anti-drone-systems-india-security/

https://www.vifindia.org/article/2023/june/09/Drone-Threat-is-Real-India-Needs-a-Comprehensive-Counter-Drone-Strategy

https://www.ijraset.com/research-paper/a-comprehensive-review-of-modern-counter-drone-technologies-trends-challenges

https://web.iitd.ac.in/~dharmar/paper/PriyankaOpsearch2024.pdf

https://capsindia.org/wp-content/uploads/2023/07/New-Delhi-Ppaer-No.-10-Gp-Capt-Amitabh-Mathur.pdf

https://www.business-standard.com/article/current-affairs/drone-like-object-spotted-at-delhi-s-igi-airport-flight-ops-hit-twice-117082100028_1.html

https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/publications/c-uas-tech-guide_final_28feb2020.pdf

https://media.defense.gov/2021/Jan/07/2002561080/-1/-1/1/DEPARTMENT-OF-DEFENSE-COUNTER-SMALL-UNMANNED-AIRCRAFT-SYSTEMS-STRATEGY.PDF

https://www.npsa.gov.uk/countering-threats-unmanned-aerial-systems-uas

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/no-infiltration-along-loc-after-ceasefire-agreement-with-pakistan-army-chief-naravane/articleshow/84014653.cms?

https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/india/neutralised-pakistani-drones-through-cds-anil-chauhan-shares-new-details-on-operation-sindoor-pitches-for-local-tech/articleshow/122554205.cms

https://www.aninews.in/news/national/general-news/drone-sighting-along-border-with-pak-tripled-in-one-year-311-observations-in-202220221226201312/

Page: https://www.dronefederation.in/media-hub/counter-drone-strategy-emerges-as-india's-next-security-priority