Knowledge Centre by Drone Federation India

Design Champion Model for Strategic Defence Acquisitions

Summary

India produces a lot of defence hardware but owns too little of the design behind it. Despite record defence production of ₹1.27 lakh crore in FY 2023-24, exports rising nearly thirty-fold over the past decade, and 38 approved Make-I projects, the current acquisition framework under the Defence Acquisition Procedure (DAP 2020) still rewards assembly and imports over indigenous design ownership. This paper identifies five recurring gaps: users default to fast imports over slower indigenous development; capability roadmaps and actual procurement decisions rarely match; Acceptance of Necessity and production procurement run as separate processes that leave firms to fund commercialisation risk alone, IP and commercialisation clauses remain ambiguous, and startups and MSMEs rarely qualify to lead as prime Development Agencies. While the Make-I category has been pivotal in underwriting high-risk indigenous R&D for projects like Tactical Communication Systems and Future Infantry Combat Vehicles, it lacks financial mechanisms to scale prototypes into production and offers no guaranteed procurement. The proposed fix is a Design Champion Model: a demand-led, design-first acquisition pathway with a long-term capability roadmap, compulsory indigenous design for strategically important platforms, milestone-based funding, and guaranteed procurement for successful domestic design, governed through a structure from the Ministry of Defence down to a Development Agency built around three roles, designer, financer and manufacturer, and benchmarked against defence acquisition models in the US, Australia, the UK, France and Japan.

Details

India produces a lot of defence hardware but owns too little of the design behind it. Despite record production of ₹1.27 lakh crore in FY 2023-24 and 38 approved Make-I projects, the current acquisition framework still rewards assembly over indigenous design ownership. Operational imperatives often tilt user preferences toward "Buy" categories, since they minimise near-term risk and compress trial timelines as compared to importing proven foreign technologies, which demotivates the mid-to-long-term indigenous R&D that Make and IDDM pathways are meant to encourage. Many iDEX and Make-II projects reach TRL 5-7 but rarely transition into fleet-level orders, leaving startups and MSMEs trapped in what the paper calls a " valley of death ."

The recurring gaps in the framework include:

• Users default to fast imports over slower indigenous development.

• Capability roadmaps and actual procurement decisions rarely match.

• Acceptance of Necessity (AoN) and production procurement run as separate processes , leaving firms to fund commercialisation risk alone.

• IP and commercialisation clauses remain ambiguous .

• Startups and MSMEs rarely qualify to lead as prime Development Agencies.

The proposed fix is a Design Champion Model: a demand-led, design-first acquisition pathway with a long-term capability roadmap guided by war-gaming, scenario planning and user feedback, compulsory indigenous design for strategically important platforms, milestone-based funding through spiral design cycles, and guaranteed procurement for successful domestic design. The model applies to capital acquisition cases classified as under high-technology, high-investment and long-gestation, typically requiring four to six years of development, and is meant to build confidence among Tier-1 design companies and Tier-2/3 suppliers to diversify into the defence sector. It sets out a clear governance structure, from the Ministry of Defence down to a Development Agency built around three roles: designer, financer and manufacturer. The model is benchmarked against defence acquisition frameworks in the US (DARPA-driven prime integrator model), Australia (CASG-led acquisition), the UK (DSTL-style innovation), France (national lead integrator model), and Japan (ATLA-led mechanism).

Read the full whitepaper for the complete gap analysis, global benchmarks and institutional design.

Page: https://www.dronefederation.in/knowledge-centre/design-champion-model-for-strategic-defence-acquisitions