Media Hub by Drone Federation India

How are drones shaping psychological dynamics in modern warfare?

Article

Psychological warfare refers to strategic methods to create a psychological reaction and instil fear by reducing the morale of the enemy. Traditionally, this aspect of warfare is employed through propaganda, coercion, and misinformation. The psychological dimension of warfare has deepened with the growing use of drones. Drones are not only inflicting physical damage but also causing psychological harm. The ubiquity of drones in wars, attacks and operations, along with the trending focus in mainstream social media platforms, accumulates mentally on enemies. The psychological impact ranges from fear to stress, depending on the individual’s experience and background. This mirrors a psychological pattern observed in past wars, such as shell shock of WWI and battle fatigue of WWII. This snowball effect of drones is reshaping modern warfare globally.

The role of drones has evolved from a second line of defence to the first line of defence. Drones are everywhere in modern conflicts, including Ukraine-Russia, Nagorno-Karabakh, Iran-Israel and more. Drones serve in diverse ways in these conflicts. They are used as ISR platforms (Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance) for real-time situational awareness and targeting. Loitering munitions are used for waiting overhead to take down targets. HALE (High Altitude Long Endurance) and MALE (Medium Altitude Long Endurance) are for extended range and altitude. Kamikaze and FPV drones are for targeting high-value objectives by crashing into them with a payload. Beyond their tactical roles, drones now act as a psychological tool.

“The drones were terrifying... it is impossible to determine who or what they are tracking... the buzz of a distant propeller is a constant reminder of imminent death.” These were the words of a journalist who was kidnapped by the Taliban in 2008. The civilians constitute the majority of those most affected by these drones. The buzzing sound of drones acts as a psychological trigger, inducing anxiety, panic and hypervigilance. It is observed that civilians in such environments face chronic stress and behaviour change with altered routines, fear of outdoors and a feeling that they are under surveillance. There were reports of insomnia, psychosomatic symptoms, fainting, and hallucinations after drone encounters. “Learned Helplessness” is a psychological theory proposed by Martin Seligman in 1967 that explains these effects. As described by Seligman, repeated, unpredictable threats cause people to feel powerless, leading to passivity and depressive symptoms.

The psychological impact on frontline soldiers is based on unique psychological triggers apart from the buzzing sound. They are the initial victims of drone psychological warfare. Prolonged alertness, startle responses, and mental exhaustion are key indicators of this effect, repeating the patterns of shell shock and battle fatigue from earlier wars. Soldiers anticipate the activity of drones, which creates stress and anxiety. This phenomenon is termed “Anticipatory Anxiety”. Carl Larson, an Iraq veteran who was born in Seattle and served in Ukraine's International Legion, said that the huge presence of drones is "a horrendous detriment to morale." Classical Conditioning, in 1897, a theory by Ivan Pavlov, explains the above effects. Pavlov explained how an automatic, conditioned response is paired with a specific stimulus. In this case, exposure to drone threats conditions soldiers with fear of certain sounds or sights, leading to trauma. This trauma often lasts even after service. An example to describe this theory is the startled response of veterans to a small cracker, which is due to their prolonged exposure to explosives on the battlefield.

The impact is not limited to those on the receiving end but also to those who operate these drones. Drone operators are burdened despite being physically far from the conflict. This is a paradox in itself. Operators are physically far but emotionally invested, monitoring live feeds for hours in dark and confined spaces separated from homes, often forming psychological connections with targets and troops. Studies conducted on drone crews have shown a higher prevalence of psychiatric symptoms than their counterparts who operate manned aircraft. The majority of studies were conducted on drone operators of Reaper and Global Hawk. They are subject to PTSD (Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder) and moral injury. They suffered from emotional detachment, guilt over strikes, witnessing deaths, and conflicts of morals. About 46–48% of drone operators report significant psychiatric symptoms such as sadness, guilt, irritability, poor concentration, and anxiety. An estimated 8.2% received a formal mental health diagnosis within the first 24 months of service in these roles. Leon Festinger proposed a theory named Cognitive Dissonance in 1957, pointing out that people seek internal consistency in their thoughts and actions. When experiences conflict between beliefs and behaviour, it creates psychological discomfort. To reduce this, they may rationalise their actions, adopt beliefs like the just-world theory, focus only on supporting information, or avoid situations that challenge their views.

Recent research and statistical studies highlight the psychological toll on civilians, soldiers and drone operators. Due to the ongoing Russia-Ukraine war, reports claim that civilians are undergoing a lot of behavioural changes and experiencing increased anxiety due to the increased drone activity and induced fear. Drone operators face unique challenges, including nearly 30% experiencing clinical burnout, and PTSD affects 4% to 5% of them, especially with longer deployments and extended work hours. Experts describe this as a “psychological whiplash” from shifting abruptly between combat and normal life, increasing risks of burnout and adjustment issues. Military experts now view drones as deliberate psychological weapons, intensifying fear and stress. Stigma around mental health complicates the treatment among drone operators and soldiers. Thus, drones cause a lasting psychological impact across all affected groups. This demands urgent attention in military training and mental health care.

Building resilience through mitigation and post-recovery takes utmost priority. Integrating drones into regular exercises helps build familiarity and reduces trauma. Training also includes cognitive behavioural therapy and realistic exposure therapy. Timely psychological support, early identification of trauma symptoms, and destigmatisation of seeking care are critical. Peer support and embedded clinical staff improve results. Better leadership and organisational support units make them less susceptible to psychological casualties. Mentoring, support, and recognition help neutralise the effects of burnout. These methods will help tackle the psychological impact of drones. Drones have transformed modern warfare to cause physical destruction and intense psychological trauma. "He who controls the air controls everything," wrote General Giulio Douhet in the early 20th century. The wide adoption of drones today indeed proves his statement. Therefore, this control extends beyond the battlefield into human minds, influencing behaviour, decision-making, and morale. Military strategies must address these mental and emotional impacts as conflicts evolve.

References:

https://moderndiplomacy.eu/2023/02/28/military-drones-a-formidable-psychological-tool-on-the-battlefield/

https://warontherocks.com/2023/06/its-time-to-think-about-and-fear-drones-and-psychological-operations/

https://oe.tradoc.army.mil/product/drones-having-psychological-impact-on-soldiers/

https://christopherjferguson.com/Drones.pdf

https://www.hillandponton.com/ptsd-in-drone-operators-and-pilots/

https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2015/01/16/377508731/report-high-levels-of-burnout-in-u-s-drone-pilots

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8645297/

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0165178116303435

https://www.visionofhumanity.org/how-drones-have-shaped-the-nature-of-conflict/

https://real.mtak.hu/218773/1/2024_76_kulonszam_91.pdf

https://dras.in/impact-of-drones-in-battlefield/

https://3sjournal.com/the-impact-of-drone-technology-on-intelligence-practices/

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/military/drone-pilot-burnout-triggers-call-recruiting-overhaul-n450526

https://www.iwm.org.uk/events/beware-blue-skies-the-psychology-of-drone-warfare

https://moderndiplomacy.eu/2022/10/31/from-surveillance-to-supremacy-drones-in-contemporary-conflicts/

https://www.thebureauinvestigates.com/stories/2011-08-10/drones-cause-mass-trauma-among-civilians

https://www.sofmag.com/how-drones-broke-the-rules-of-war/

Page: https://www.dronefederation.in/media-hub/drones-shaping-psycological-dynamics-in-modern-warfare