Media Hub by Drone Federation India

Reimagining India’s Defence Innovation Pipeline Through Design Leadership

Article

Background

India’s modern defence development journey truly took shape in 1958, when the government consolidated various technical establishments to create the Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO). 1 The advent of 1947–48 Indo-Pakistan conflict and later 1962 war with China, both exposed the precarious condition of India’s border security. As India faced the hardening geopolitics of nuclear armed and increasingly assertive neighbours, it recognised that lasting security rested on building and producing advanced defence platforms indigenously.

This urgency was also reflected in Parliament. As early as the mid-1970s, the Public Accounts Committee observed that domestic ammunition production was faltering and relied heavily on imported manufacturing plants. It noted that “the old plant lost its capability, resulting in heavy rejections and unreliable production. Such assessments reinforced that India’s defence ambitions could not rest on foreign hardware but on the strength of its own scientific and industrial ecosystem. 2

Licensed Production: Capability Without Control

It was this recognition that shaped the next phase of India’s defence industrial evolution, which moved into licensed production. India sought to absorb foreign technology by manufacturing proven systems through transfer of technology arrangements. This phase saw the assembly of major frontline platforms such as MiG-21, Jaguar, and later the Su-30MKI through agreements with foreign OEMs. 345 Yet true strategic autonomy remained out of reach.

Make-I: Ambition Meets Structural Constraints

A major structural reform arrived in 2006 with the introduction of Make-I route. It was designed to address the foundational constraints of India’s defence industrial base. These constraints include limited core design capability, absence of sustained funding for long-cycle R&D and advanced testing infrastructure. Make-I projects are usually touted as a model needed for establishing extremely large “multi-thousand” crore defence equipments. In practice, these projects matter because they are tied to systems that shape the future of warfare. Some of the Make-I projects that are currently underway include, Long Range Land Attack Cruise Missile, Fixed-Wing Based High Altitude Pseudo Satellite, Multiband Programmable RF Sensor Satellite, Indian Light Tank, Future Ready Combat Vehicle-Armoured Fighting Vehicle FRCV-AFV, Medium Speed Marine Diesel Engine etc. 6 While Make-I created an institutional mechanism for high-value indigenous development, it still required a sharper policy push to prioritise Indian intellectual property at the core of procurement.

This sharper prioritisation arrived a decade later. A decisive shift was formalised in 2016 when the Defence Procurement Procedure (DPP) 2016, under the stewardship of the late Defence Minister Manohar Parrikar, introduced the Indigenously Designed, Developed and Manufactured (IDDM) category. 7 The category prioritised Indian intellectual property through Indian design authority, and domestic value addition. This marked a turning point from “build-to-print” manufacturing to genuine defence innovation.

In accordance with the IDDM philosophy, the government introduced a series of innovation-centric programmes aimed at expanding India’s deep-tech capacity. The iDEX (Innovations for Defence Excellence) initiative, launched in 2018, created a nationwide pipeline for supporting start-ups, MSMEs and young engineers working on futuristic defence technologies. 8 This innovation system was further strengthened with the launch of the ADITI scheme in 2024, which provides direct financial support for high-risk, high-impact R&D aimed at strategic and battlefield-critical technologies. Together, iDEX and ADITI transformed the innovation landscape by ensuring that Indian products could originate at the design table, not merely the assembly line. 9

As these reforms took hold, the Make in India era has catalysed unprecedented FDI inflows into defence manufacturing, especially after the cap was raised to 74% under automatic route in 2020. 10 This enabled the rise of major Indian defence primes like HAL, L&T Defence, Bharat Forge, SMPP, Adani Defence, and others. Their growth followed a predictable pathway of forging strategic partnerships with foreign OEMs, initiating technology-transfer-based production, and the creating extensive assembly lines for aircraft, armoured platforms, artillery, and ammunition. This expansion generated large-scale manufacturing capacity, thousands of specialised jobs, and a strong revenue base for Indian industry.

Even as India’s Defence Industrial Base strengthened, structural gaps inherent in innovation pathways such as Make-I, iDEX and ADITI continue to prevent promising technologies from maturing into deployable systems. Make-I, intended to incubate complex, high-value indigenous systems, has repeatedly placed disproportionate financial risk on industry while offering uncertain rewards.

The Battle Management System (BMS) collapsed despite years of work because Development Agencies were forced to absorb excessive financial risk amid inconsistent government funding. The Tactical Communication System (TCS) reached successful prototype development, yet stalled due to delayed fund disbursements and the absence of a guaranteed procurement pipeline, signalling to industry that even technical success does not ensure acquisition. The Future Infantry Combat Vehicle (FICV) project has spent over a decade cycling through restarts and revised Expressions of Interest, never progressing beyond the “perpetual prototype” stage.

These structural weaknesses are not limited to Make-I. iDEX while celebrated for bringing start-ups to the forefront, has faced criticism for limited absorption of solutions. The challenges that impair absorption of solutions include, obtaining funding, access to toolsets and datasets, and navigating stringent defence regulations. 11

The more recent ADITI scheme expands funding for start-ups, yet early feedback from industry highlights familiar concerns such as fragmented testing infrastructure, slow integration with Service requirements and absence of a dedicate path from prototype to production. 12 Together, these fault lines have led to high exposure for private firms and a broken bridge between innovation and induction. Thus, highlighting the need for a systemic redesign rather than incremental fixes.

For India to break this cycle and genuinely compete in the next era of warfare, it must widen its horizon of future-ready weapon systems and adopt a hybrid acquisition architecture that fuses Make-I, Buy (Indian-IDDM), and iDEX-driven innovation. Each route solves a different part of the capability puzzle. Make-I enables high-value, government-funded prototype development. IDDM prioritises sovereign design and Indian IP. iDEX injects speed and disruptive thinking into defence technologies. India already possesses the two halves of a powerful defence engine that is large defence primes like HAL, L&T Defence, Bharat Forge, and Adani Defence with deep manufacturing capacity, and a rapidly growing startup ecosystem that has produced over 600+ tech startups under iDEX. 13

What is missing is an acquisition model that enables spiral development for systems that are not traditional legacy platforms such as fighter aircraft, submarines or long-range surface-to-air missile systems but newer categories that enable asymmetric capability. These include loitering munitions, kamikaze drones, autonomous swarm drones, counter-drone systems, man-portable precision-strike UAVs etc.

A spiral pathway would allow these fast-evolving systems to mature through iterative upgrades rather than waiting for monolithic “block” acquisitions. It would also enable India to fuse the industrial depth of defence primes with the technical agility of start-ups developing frontier technologies.

The Model

The Design Champion Model re-aligns India’s defence ecosystem around design leadership rather than mere manufacturing. Unlike legacy models that separate design, funding, and manufacturing into disconnected silos, the Design Champion Model integrates accountability across the entire lifecycle, from architecture to induction.

It lays ground for coming together of three stakeholders within a consortium - the Designer, the Financer and the Manufacturer. The Designer leads innovation and architecture, accomplishing the objective of indigenous IP. The Financer sustains risk-sharing and capital infusion. Allowing de-risking of both government and industry from large upfront, one-time outlays. The Manufacturer leverages existing facilities developed during the days of licensed production to now manufacture for India. This triadic structure embeds accountability across the entire design to production continuum.

An intrinsic part of the model is spiral development process, where systems evolve through iterative design-test-refine cycles rather than fulfilling a single, monolithic requirement. This allows the designer to incorporate technological breakthroughs, user feedback and battlefield learning at every turn, ensuring platforms remain adaptive and future-ready instead of becoming obsolete by the time they enter service.

It is to be noted that each spiral culminates in a mandatory technology demonstration, allowing the Services to evaluate performance in real conditions before greenlighting the next iteration. These demonstrations create transparent checkpoints, prevent projects from drifting into indefinite timelines, and offer early visibility into the system’s viability, thereby reducing the infamous “valley of death” between prototype and production.

Unlike legacy acquisition routes, the Design Champion Model links development success directly to guaranteed procurement. Once a system meets its demonstrated performance parameters and final spiral objectives, procurement is automatically triggered at pre determined quantities.

Expected Outcomes

The Design Champion Model when implemented, supported by budgetary allocation and embedded within the perspective planning cycles can drive a fundamental reset in India’s defence capital procurements.

The model combines fiscal predictability with spiral development pathways, that are needed for development of complex platforms such as autonomous swarm drones, battle management systems and lightweight combat vehicles etc. This combination enables such technologies to evolve iteratively rather than expire as prototypes.

The milestone based funding and audit mechanisms introduce budgetary prudence without staggering innovation. Additionally, integrated user feedback loops at prototype and technology demonstration level ensures that operational realities are factored in design stage itself. This ensures that the acquired platforms meet both stated and latent operational requirements.

Over time, this model can seed a globally competitive defence design ecosystem fostered indigenously. Such an ecosystem which is devised by India’s primes and startups not only meet domestic needs but also exports next-generation systems under Indian IP.

The Design Champion Model offers India a chance to ensure that self-reliance is measured not by what is built, but by what is fielded. This ambition will no longer be a veil for mere assembly of foreign components but a launchpad for design, development and delivery of such systems.

References:

• https://www.indiascienceandtechnology.gov.in/organisations/ministry-and-departments/defence-research-and-development-organisation-drdo

• https://eparlib.sansad.in/bitstream/123456789/4930/1/pac_6_3_1978.pdf

• https://www.twz.com/air/indias-iconic-mig-21-blasts-off-into-retirement

• https://indianexpress.com/article/explained/churu-crash-why-iaf-continues-to-fly-the-vintage-sepecat-jaguar-10116206/

• https://thedefensepost.com/2025/10/31/armenia-india-su30mki-deal/#:~:text=Su%2D30MKI:%20India's%20Flagship%20Fighter,Aeronautics%20Limited%20(HAL)%20India%20Sukhoi

• https://makeinindiadefence.gov.in/make1-project-list

• https://www.mod.gov.in/sites/default/files/dppm.pdf_0.pdf

• https://idex.gov.in/idex

• https://www.ddpmod.gov.in/offerings/schemes-and-services/807

• https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleasePage.aspx?PRID=2004475&

• https://www.idsa.in/publisher/issuebrief/helping-start-ups-cross-the-valley-of-death-the-main-challenge-for-idex

• https://impriinsights.in/acing-development-of-innovative-technologies-with-idex-aditi-scheme-2024-boosting-indias-defence-innovation-impri-impact-and-policy-research-institute/

• https://www.pib.gov.in/PressReleseDetailm.aspx?PRID=2114546#:~:text=Innovations%20for%20Defence%20Excellence%20(iDEX)&text=As%20of%20February%202025%2C%20549,have%20been%20approved%20for%20development .

Page: https://www.dronefederation.in/media-hub/reimagining-indias-defence-innovation-pipeline-through-design-leadership